November Update:
At last months Forum meeting, we were joined by the Councils Exempt Accommodation Team. They talked about the work they do and we discussed concerns raised by residents. There were a number of actions we are following up on:
1) reporting of issues from the community to the Council and the EA Team needs to improve. Issues we heard off when compiling case studies of problem properties were not known about. Our Councillors have made this one of their priorities for 2025 and we will work with them and the police to see what can be done. As a reminder, if you think the has been a crime, report it to the police on 101, via Crime Stoppers link or contact our local team link . Also report to the Council's exempt accommodation team along with any antisocial behaviour and issues with rubbish. The best way to do this is to email prs@birmingham.gov.uk
2) There is legislation for a licensing scheme which is in the consultation team. Our MP is lobbying for this to be enacted as soon as possible and for Selly Park to be a pilot area.
3) there was concern about how issues are dealt with when reported to the Council and the lack of feedback from them. A working group is being setup to see how this can be improved.
4) The Council's cabinet member for Housing has heard about our concerns and wishes to visit the area to understand them and discuss how the situation can be improved.
The EA have produced a summary of what they do and their recent activity in our area
August Update:
It has been a frustrating time trying to make any progress on exempt accommodation, largely due to the general election. Since our last post:
• We met with the new Councillor, Jamie Scott, after his election in May. He has experience of EA, he is keen to try and help us and also believes there is a case for targeted action in Selly Park. Unfortunately, little progress had been made until I met him this month when he’d had a response from the EA Team. They say they are willing to support a meeting with us and residents to discuss the situation. They also said they haven't had many complaints about Selly Park properties, so I've sent the document of case studies we created to Jamie to pass onto them. It feels like they aren't aware of the day to day, ongoing issues that our everyone is experiencing. Please continue to keep a diary of any incidents you experience so we can pass them on.
• Jamie and I thought it would be good to try and get them to the next Selly Park South meeting on the 20th of August to get feedback from residents as a first step, but it looks unlikely to happen. We will keep chasing for a meeting if it doesn’t happen.
• We met with the new MP, Al Carns, at the end of July. We took him through the situation in Selly Park and the work Steve McCabe was doing on our behalf to try and arrange a meeting with the EA team, try to get the upcoming legislation implemented as soon as possible and see if there could be a pilot study. He says he is going to get up to speed with the case file and he was going to follow up with the housing minister about implementing the legislation.
• The actions from the meeting Cllr Francis (see March update below) have not happened. Jon and Barry from the Exempt Accommodation Forum are chasing this.
March Update:
Firstly, we wanted to remind everyone to keep reporting any issues to the authorities. If you think the has been a crime, report it to the police on 101 or via Crime Stoppers link. Also report to the Council's exempt accommodation team along with any antisocial behaviour and issues with rubbish. The best way to do this is to email prs@birmingham.gov.uk
Our MP, Steve McCabe, on the 2nd. He is still pushing for a meeting with the housing minister to see if there's progress on the legislation, if it can be pulled forward and whether a pilot project is possible. He has enquired about arranging a meeting of a multidisciplinary team to tackle issues in Selly Park. He has received feedback that there is a team already in existence. We have supplied them details of the problem properties which have so far been reported to us and asked for a meeting to see how we can work with them.
We are now part of the city wide Exempt Accommodation Forum. They arranged a meeting with Cllr Francis, Cabinet Member for Housing, and EA officers on the 20th of March to discuss tackling EA issues city wide. We presented the issues in Selly Park. The main points:
There was a commitment to work with EA Forum and community groups to tackle issues. The Council believe they have the processes in place to do this but the community are seeing a deterioration in the situation.
Cllr Francis to visit some of the areas with EA issues to see the problems first hand.
Commitment to review the EA Forum's learning of best practise from other authorities
Agreement for regular meetings every two months.
We are continuing to gather evidence on problem properties as it builds the case for action whether through the working group, the pilot or the future legislation. We are arranging interviews with those who have raised concerns and looking at how we can make it easier for residents to report issues. In the meantime, please keep a diary of date, time, nature of issue, whether it was reported and what the response was. If you have a problem property you want included, please let us know.
Feb Update: We are continuing to with two other Selly Park community groups (SPOA and Selly Park Residents Community Association) and the Exempt Accommodation Forum (a Birmingham wide pressure group that gave evidence to the House of Commons Committee) to apply pressure to the Council and police to tackle the issues inside and outside of the badly run properties. If you aren't sure what exempt accommodation is, there are details further down this post.
We are actively consulting our residents to understand the issues in area. This started with our Forum's Open Meeting on the 23rd of January where we heard of issues residents of these properties and their neighbours have.
We are compiling a database of problem households. If you are affected, keep reporting to the police and our councillors but also let us know by emailing to sellyparksouth@yahoo.co.uk Keep a diary of any problems. Record the date, how long it went on for, the nature of the incident and if you contacted anyone about it, what was the response.
We have supplied problem addresses to the police so that they can supply their records of incidents with EA properties.
Cllr McCarthy has committed to find addresses which have been raised with our Councillors.
We met with our MP and our Councillors on the 3rd of February. We collectively agreed that:
We want to deter further EAs in our area as we are already saturated.
We want to ensure that residents in those households have suitable accommodation, that the mix of residents is appropriate and they have effective care plans.
We want to ensure any issues caused to local residents are resolved quickly. Where long-term issues exist, long-term solutions should be applied. Where necessary, this should involve benefits being withheld from the providers.
We believe there needs to be a multidisciplinary team involving the Council, Police and local residents to target the worst properties in Selly Park using the existing powers that aren't being effectively used. These should include all the main providers in our area. The hope is that this will provide a deterrent to new, badly run properties and reduce the number of problems we have.
We will also use this team to see whether we can get a pilot study for the licencing scheme that is in upcoming legislation.
We discussed with Steve what he could do to help.
Following an earlier meeting, he is trying to get a debate in the Commons on the ongoing issues with exempt accommodation. He had previously committed to see if there was a way to get the legislation enacted sooner and whether a pilot licencing scheme was possible.
He has also been trying to arrange a meeting with the local police inspector to raise his concerns.
Steve agreed to arrange a working meeting involving the Councillors, Police, local resident's groups, the Council's Exempt Accommodation Team, Adult Social Services and the Housing Benefits Team. This will look at how we can make the team happen and how it can meet our aims.
We discussed with our councillors as to how they could help
While they are waiting for the meeting, they will be making the relevant Council Officers aware of what we are trying to do and to find the right people to invite to the working meeting.
What is exempt accommodation?
Exempt accommodation (EA) is housing where vulnerable adults are supported to live independently. It could be accommodation for:
people who are homeless
people recently released from prison
survivors of domestic abuse
people with substance dependencies
people with mental health issues
refugees
In the Forum's area there are 45+ properties (most are on Pershore Road) housing over 200 people. These are run by providers who are given around £3 million per year in benefits to provide accommodation and support. Unfortunately there is little regulation and some providers aren't providing any support to EA residents but are exploiting them. To quote from a House of Commons Committee report who visited Erdington as part of their research link
"The very worst experiences we heard were of residents living among, and being made, the victims of the most terrible crimes, sometimes at the hands of staff. Stories included residents being raped and sexually harassed by their landlords under threat of eviction. We heard of staff assaulting residents and asking them for sexual acts in return for money, food, or better accommodation. We were told of residents forced to undertake work on the property, such as tiling a bathroom, for nothing or for a pittance. Staff and landlords were accused of threatening residents, selling drugs to residents and being complicit in anti-social behaviour. Residents have also been victims of crimes committed by fellow residents, such as sexual assault and burglaries. It has also been recently reported that “organised crime groups are taking millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money [and] have been cashing in on the recent boom in exempt accommodation”. West Midlands Police’s written evidence described how organised crime groups typically invest in real estate as a front to launder money. The impact of experiences such as these is that some people, who are already vulnerable when they enter exempt accommodation on the promise that they will receive support, become more traumatised than before. For other residents, the cost of their exempt accommodation has been their very lives, some people dying of drug overdoses and others even being murdered by fellow residents."
The report also highlights the knock on effect that badly run EAs can have on the community
"...we also heard many accounts of anti-social and criminal behaviour taking place near exempt accommodation. Much, but by no means all, of this evidence came from community groups in and around Birmingham, where there is a great deal of awareness and activism on the part of local groups. Contributors to our inquiry described littering, rubbish piling up and pouring over the streets, encouraging the spread of vermin and cockroaches. More than one submission mentioned residents begging. There were also reports of noise from parties, fights, and quarrels. We were also told about drug taking, littering, public urination, and in one area, prostitution. These problems were exacerbated when exempt properties were clustered together in the same area. West Midlands Police wrote that they received 18 calls in one month from just one road with a high concentration of exempt accommodation."
"Neighbourhood groups were also concerned about a loss of family housing that they associated with exempt accommodation, as Victorian era properties can be easily converted to multiple occupation. Centre for the New Midlands, a think tank, claimed that since 2014 over 5,000 homes have been converted from family homes to exempt accommodation in the Midlands alone."
Comments